Tuesday, 30 October 2012

Charity vs taxes and the destruction of the state

From the FT this week, a story on John Paulson's $100 million donation to the Central Park Conservancy.  The article focuses on the idea that charitable organizations can step in for government to provide public goods, and why that idea is pernicious:
[America]’s philanthropy is unique. Its two key institutions are the tax deduction for charitable gifts and the tax-exempt foundation. Noting the role of the Ford Foundation in Lyndon Johnson’s “war on poverty” in the 1960s, Daniel Patrick Moynihan, the late senator, called foundations a “new level of American government”. 
Americans pat themselves on the back for their generosity, not always with good reason. Olivier Zunz, a historian of philanthropy at the University of Virginia, calls American charity a “capitalist venture in social betterment, not an act of kindness as understood in Christianity”. 
Giving to a foundation can be self-interested – a way for a rich person to launder economic power that he does not need into political power that he does. Foundations inevitably get politicised, not because donors are corrupt or insincere but because they are rational. Lobbying for a piece of a government budget is a more efficient way of serving most causes than simply spending donations.
Note that this story comes on the heels of the recent news about how presidential candidate Mitt Romney has used donations to the Mormon church to secure huge tax breaks for himself, even while he campaigns to dismantle agencies like FEMA.  True to form, the Heritage Foundation has suggested that the right answer to Sandy and other natural disasters is for the private sector to support charities like the Red Cross.  It is ironic that Heritage begins its discussion by lauding the fact that "Americans are already coming together to help family, friends, and neighbors."  Isn't that, after all, the whole point of our democratic society: people come together and decide how to govern themselves, including how and when to help each other when disaster strikes someone you don't know personally but who is part of your larger community?

We need only look a little closer at the Red Cross to see the utter silliness of the Heritage foundation's response.  From the Red Cross website:

We have the legal status of “a federal instrumentality,” due to our charter requirements to carry out responsibilities delegated to us by the federal government. Among these responsibilities are:
  • to fulfill the provisions of the Geneva Conventions, to which the United States is a signatory, assigned to national societies for the protection of victims of conflict,
  • to provide family communications and other forms of support to the U.S. military, and
  • to maintain a system of domestic and international disaster relief, including mandated responsibilities under the National Response Framework coordinated by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).
Yes, the federal government and the several states contract (pay) the Red Cross to fulfill government functions, even on occasion appropriating funds for the direct support of this organization.  It is not an independent charity that sinks or swims on the altruism or lack thereof of the giving class.  It is a public/private hybrid that relies on donors and the government, and--more importantly--that follows direction from the government in responding to matters involving the common good.  It is not, in other words, subject solely to the whims of its donors in deciding what public goods to provide.


The dismissal of FEMA that characterizes organizations like Heritage and sympathetic politicians like Romney and Ryan even while they laud charitable organizations like the Red Cross betrays the utter emptiness of their fundamental mistrust of "government" as well as that of their trust in the private sector to furnish necessary public goods.

The central problem with relying on purely private charities to provide public goods like disaster relief is not that the donors are self-serving (they are) but that in promoting a mythical idea of a private sector that solves public goods problems without any coordination from government, you have to believe that such a sector exists and further that is can and will accurately assess public needs and mete out coherent responses.  That involves a lot of faith in individuals and organizations that are subject to any number of cognitive biases and mistakes even while they are not subject to the same level of scrutiny to which we can subject government.  The FT says, "most charity does some good for someone, at the price of a certain corruption."  True enough, but what are we to do about public goods problems that rich donors don't find compelling or interesting enough to support?  Moreover, where is the accountability if no private charity steps up to meet a given demand or that in responding to a real and serious demand, bungles the job?

That is why the Red Cross' mandate from the federal government to respond to FEMA reveals the bankrupt idea of anti-government sentiment when it comes to disaster management in particular and government vs charity more broadly.  We should be very skeptical of any attempt to wrest the mandate to provide public goods out of the hands of government and into the hands of the private sector alone.

The FT concludes:
[Mr. Paulson's gift raises] no worries that well-heeled experts are bypassing or steering democratic processes. It simply puts a large fortune at the disposal of a beloved and perennially underfunded institution. There is no better use for a billionaire’s money, short of taxing it.
That's the right answer.  Taxes are what we pay for a civilized society: one in which public goods problems are identified, assessed, and responded to in a way that can be in turn assessed, evaluated, and yes criticised when necessary (cf: Katrina).  That accountability loop exists in government, even if imperfectly.  It is not the same for individual donors or purely private charities.  Churchill's famous quote about democracy holds true for taxing and spending.  It's the worst way to fix public goods problems except for everything else.

Monday, 29 October 2012

Capital Flight and Tax Competition

Allison posted an extremely interesting article discussing capital flight from Africa (there were two studies, one for North Africa and one for Sub-Saharan Africa).  While there are clearly development and finance issues implicated by this, I am most interested in the tax consequences.

Capital flight from poor countries confounds traditional tax analysis.  Neo-classical economics provides that capital should flow from rich countries to poor countries; since poor countries need it more, they will have higher demand and thus pay more for it.  The problem is that this has rarely been observed in real life.  Nobel laureate Robert Lucas first identified this in the context of Colonial India, where significantly less capital flowed from England than would be expected under neo-classical models.  This was so contradictory to accepted wisdom it was dubbed the "Lucas Paradox."  Yet the empirical research, including the articles cited by Allison, keeps finding this result, over time and among countries.

The Lucas Paradox has received a fair amount of attention in economics literature, but far less in tax literature.  Instead, the driving policy behind international tax has been "neutrality" - that is, minimize tax distortions to capital flows around the world.  The theory provides that neutral tax laws would increase efficiency as they would permit capital to go where it is needed most.  But what if capital doesn't flow to high demand countries even when the tax laws are neutral?  In that case, I argue, certain countries may have no choice but to engage in tax competition just to attract some minimal amounts of capital.

If neutral tax laws are in fact creating or exacerbating incentives for certain poorer countries to engage in tax competition, presumably that should be taken into account when structuring US tax laws.  In other words, if the same model that predicted capital flows to poorer countries also recommends neutrality as the primary policy goal of international tax, why shouldn't we question that policy as well?

What would a non-neutral tax law look like?  Perhaps it would subsidize investment in poorer countries.  Perhaps it would basket income from poor countries differently than wealthy countries, or allow blending of losses across certain countries, or permit different structuring rules in such countries. This might come across as heresy to some, but in fact this used to be US tax policy , before it was repealed in the 1970s in the name of neutrality.

The real lesson may be that there are no "first best" solutions to international tax.  Neutral tax laws may work best for wealthy countries but could lead to intensified tax competition from poorer countries, while non-neutral laws could distort economic decision-making in, at best, a second-best manner.  This may not be a deeply satisfying answer, but simply pretending the empirical results don't exist doesn't seem any better.

Missing billions: capital flight from Africa

TJN reports on a paper by LĂ©once Ndikumana and James K. Boyce, Capital Flight from Sub-Saharan African Countries: Updated Estimates, 1970 - 2010

Here is the abstract:
"The performance of Sub-Saharan African economies over the past decade has inspired optimism on the region's prospects. But the region still faces major development challenges, and it is now clear that the majority of its countries will not achieve key millennium development goals.

A key constraint to SSA's growth and development is the shortage of financing. At the same time, the sub-region is a source of large-scale capital flight, which escalated during last decade even as the region experienced growth acceleration. The group of 33 SSA countries covered by this report has lost a total of $814 billion dollars from 1970 to 2010. Boyce and Ndikumana compare this to the level of development aid and foreign direct investment received by these countries. Assuming that flight capital could have earned the modest interest rate measured by the short-term U.S. Treasury Bill rate, they find that the accumulated stock of capital flight far exceeds the external liabilities of this group of countries, making the region a "net creditor" to the rest of the world.

This report provides updated estimates of capital flight for 33 SSA countries from 1970 to 2010. It describes the methodology used to estimate capital flight and highlights important methodological differences with other existing studies. The report presents key results on capital flight both in absolute terms and in comparison to other capital flows, especially debt, aid, and foreign direct investment, as well as in relation to the size of the economy (as percentage of GDP and in per capita terms). The report stresses the urgency of efforts to stem capital flight and repatriate stolen assets as a part of the broader goals of scaling up development financing, combating corruption, and improving transparency in the global financial system."


Thursday, 25 October 2012

Add Starbucks, eBay and IKEA to the tax dodger ledger

When the list gets too long to count, will we finally come to see that tax dodging is in the fabric of the income tax as practiced by most countries today?  It is structured, systemic, and by design, not a loophole, not a bug.  It is the dominant culture.  Probably it is destroying the income tax for all intents and purposes.


Gender pay gap begins one year out of college

From Salon:

A report from the American Association of University Women (AAUW) flagged by Raw Story found that a gender earning gap usually occurs just one year after graduates leave college, with men making an average of $42,918 one year after graduation while women make an average of $35,296. The report, “Graduating to a pay gap” notes: 
“Graduating to a pay gap” finds that women working full time already earn less than their male counterparts do just one year after college graduation. Taking a closer look at the data, we find that women’s choices—college major, occupation, hours at work—do account for part of the pay gap. But about one-third of the gap remains unexplained, suggesting that bias and discrimination are still problems in the workplace.

More at the link.

Saturday, 20 October 2012

Is Romney proposing a new AMT?

Believe it or not, for a tax professor I actually have not been following the tax plans of the two candidates for president very closely ... mostly because they are both frustratingly vague.  But as of late one particular item has caught my eye: Romney's proposal to cap itemized deductions at a fixed dollar amount (not a percentage) combined with a large cut in the marginal tax rate.  The idea, I think, is that marginal tax rate reductions lower the substitution effect on labor while capping deductions offsets the revenue on a less elastic base, thus increasing growth with no revenue cost.  There is some theoretical support for a proposal like this, and some theoretical critiques as well.  But I would like to focus on a different issue.

Romney likes to say that this is a return to the Reagan tax policy.  But it seems to me this more closely matches another aspect of tax law - the AMT.  Under the AMT, taxpayers recalculate their tax liability by getting rid of a number of deductions and applying a lower marginal rate.  Sounds familiar.  Of course, Romney also proposes repealing the current AMT.  But the combined effect of repealing the existing AMT with the other proposals seems quite similar (at least to me) to repealing the entire income tax and leaving the AMT.

Romney says that his proposal will only effect the wealthy.  This was the same justification for the AMT in the first place.  In fact, I have no reason to believe this was not sincere.  Unfortunately, the experience with the AMT has not matched this expectation.

Take the Klaasen family.  According to the case, the Klaasen's faith required large families, and the Klaasens had ten children.  Under the regular income tax, the Klaasens owed very little tax due to the large number of exemptions and credits available for children, as well as other itemized deductions.  Under the AMT, however, the itemized deductions and tax benefits for children were taken away and a much lower rate applied.  Despite the lower rate, the Klaasens ended up owing significant AMT.  They sued, claiming this violated their First Amendment rights and that the AMT was not intended to reach poor families with large numbers of children.  The court disagreed, noting that the statute was clear in how it worked and was neutral as to religion on its face.

Similarly, the wealthiest rarely get hit by the AMT for one simple reason - the capital gains preference does not get taken away by the AMT.  Similarly, under Romney's plan as I understand it, the preference would not be affected (in fact, Romney proposes dropping it even further for taxpayers under some threshold).  Thus, taxpayers earning primarily capital gains (and presumably qualified dividends) won't be affected by the cap on itemized deductions.

The AMT also sneaks up on people with unexpectedly high, nonrecurring itemized deductions in any one given year, such as professors visiting at another school for less than one year.  Presumably a cap would do the same.

Perhaps the biggest problem with the AMT, however, is that the "AMT Exemption Amount" - basically the amount of income exempt from tax - is a fixed dollar amount not adjusted for inflation.  Thus, as salaries grew over time due to inflation, more and more people were thrown into the AMT.  Similarly, Romney has proposed a fixed dollar amount cap on itemized deductions.  Presumably, unless Romney proposes adjusting his itemized deduction amount for inflation, the same effect would occur under his plan.  As inflation increases salaries, more and more people would be hit by the cap.  This would increase revenue, but it would do so by taxing inflationary gains of middle class earners rather than real consumption or savings.  This was not an unexpected accident under the regular income tax, in fact CBO counted increased AMT collections without the so-called "AMT Patch" - which would offset inflation - in calculating revenue under the so-called "Bush tax cuts" in marginal tax rates.  It is also why the "AMT Patch" hits the budget every year, in increasing amounts.  (See here for a summary).


I do not know if this analysis is correct, mostly because of a lack of detail, but it seems plausible.  If true, both candidates propose raising revenue - one through higher marginal rates and one through taxing inflationary gains of earners on the margin of the deduction cap.  This really presents a true choice between theoretical tax bases, and thus is how I wish the choice was presented.  Perhaps the Wall Street Journal and New York Times editorial boards will read this?


Thursday, 18 October 2012

What's A Derivative?

From NPR's Ask a Banker, here is a great primer on derivatives from Matt Levine.  Excerpt:
I will tell you what a derivative is, but I will take a while to get there, and since I won't use words like "put option" or "synthetic CDO" you may feel cheated. That is okay. If you want to understand derivatives, you must learn to live with uncertainty, and also with feeling cheated.
In your finance textbook, if you have one, which I hope you don't because I'm just making this up, a derivative is defined as a contract whose payoffs are determined by reference to the price of some underlying variable. Derivatives, which include options, futures, forwards and swaps, allow levered and/or nonlinear bets and ...
... and let's start somewhere else.
There is a world. That world will have a future, and that future is uncertain. There are different possible states of the world, and different things will happen to you in those different states. If it's cold this winter, you will be sad, or perhaps happy if that's what you're into. If it rains tomorrow, you will get wet. If you take an economics course, you will start to talk like this.
If you are a company or an investment fund, the outcomes that you care about can pretty much be reduced to money: if it's cold this winter, individual workers and managers might be happy or sad, but the company has no feelings. The company just has money. If it's cold this winter, the company might have more money, if it's an oil company, because people will buy more oil to heat their homes. Or it might have less money, if it's in the agriculture business, because its crops will freeze. Or it might have the same amount of money, if it's, like, Facebook or whatever.
One thing you can do is graph future states of the world versus the amount of money you will have in those states. So for instance here is the money that an oil company will make this year (y-axis), graphed against the temperature this winter (x-axis):
The world is not this simple.
The world is not this simple.
This is a simple chart but you should see immediately that it's wrong, or at least not right.
Of course you can't predict how much money an oil company will make just by knowing the weather: there are many other things going on.
Matt follows this intro with more great charts and graphs to explain hedging, prediction, and risk in the derivatives market, and concludes with "Next time, maybe: What I did in banking, or, derivatives for regulatory arbitrage, or, why everything above was false."  Levine also wrote "What Investment Bankers Do All Day," another snarky and fascinating piece ("The short answer: nothing. The long answer: They're "obsequious and needy" "middlemen" who find people looking to invest money).